BlogChoosing an ERP
ERP vs accounting software: what is the difference.
Accounting software records what happened to the money. An ERP runs the work before the money moves: orders, stock, production, deliveries.
The short answer
Accounting software looks back. It records invoices, payments and expenses so the books and reports are accurate. Its main user is the accountant.
An ERP looks ahead and at what is happening now. It shows what has been ordered, what is in stock, what is being made and when it will be ready. Its users are sales, the warehouse, production and the owner.
The two are not competitors. In most companies they work together: the ERP runs the operations and accounting receives finished documents from it.
A handy test: if the question starts with “how much did we pay”, the answer is in accounting. If it starts with “when will it be ready” or “do we have enough”, the answer should be in the ERP.
What accounting software does well
- Keeps the chart of accounts and the ledger entries.
- Prepares the reports the accountant files.
- Tracks receivables and payables by document.
- Keeps the history of payments and expenses.
This is important work and it doesn’t go away with an ERP. The books stay where your accountant keeps them today.
Some accounting packages also include simple stock or invoicing. For a company with few items and no production, that is often all it needs.
Accounting software is built around the document: invoice, payment, receipt. It is accurate once the document exists. That makes it strong at reporting and weak at planning tomorrow.
What an ERP adds
An ERP takes on the work accounting software was never designed for. That work happens before there is an invoice.
- Quotes and orders with a status: accepted, in production, ready, shipped.
- Stock by warehouse, location and batch, with reservations for orders.
- Recipes, work orders and material consumption in production.
- Purchase orders based on actual demand.
- Cost and margin per order, not just for the month.
- An owner’s dashboard with data as it happens.
An ERP is built around the process: an order that moves through stages and people. Documents are a result of the process, not its starting point. That is why an ERP can warn you that material will run out before it does.
Where they overlap
The confusion comes from invoices and stock. Both systems can issue invoices and show stock levels. The difference is where the data comes from.
In accounting software, the invoice is usually typed in by hand, often from an email or a spreadsheet. In an ERP, the invoice is made from the order, which has already passed through the warehouse. Quantities and prices are not retyped.
Stock works the same way. Accounting stock shows the value of goods based on documents. Operational stock in an ERP shows where the goods are, which order they are reserved for and when they will run out.
The two views don’t contradict each other; they answer different questions. The accountant asks what the stock is worth. The warehouse asks whether it is on the shelf and for whom. Ideally, both answers come from the same movements, not from two separate entries.
If your bookkeeper fills in invoices from a spreadsheet the sales team sends over, the two systems already work together. Just by hand.
Example: a distribution company
Take a hypothetical distributor with, for example, 800 items and 30 orders a day. It uses only accounting software and Excel.
Sales collect orders in a spreadsheet. The warehouse picks them from a printout. The bookkeeper enters invoices in the evening. Only then is the stock level in the program updated.
The result is predictable. During the day nobody knows the exact stock. Sometimes goods are sold that are already on their way to another customer. Margin by customer is worked out once a month, and with effort.
With an ERP, the order reserves the goods as it is entered. The warehouse sees a pick list. The invoice is issued at dispatch. Accounting receives finished documents, and the owner sees margin by customer every day.
The bookkeeper in this example loses nothing. The evening invoice entry disappears, and that time can go into checking and analysis. The accounting software stays; it just stops being the only place with data.
How to decide what you need
Answer these questions honestly. The more times you answer “yes”, the clearer it is that accounting software is no longer enough.
Don’t rush the answers. Ask the people who do the work every day: they know where things are retyped and where they wait.
If you ticked one or two, tidying up the process is probably enough. If you ticked four or more, an ERP is worth a look. More on choosing one in the guide to choosing an ERP.
How they work together
The most common setup is simple. The ERP runs the operations and issues the documents. The accounting software receives the documents and keeps the books. The accountant keeps working in the tool they know.
- The order is entered and moves through the ERP.
- At dispatch, the ERP issues the invoice.
- Documents pass to the accounting software through a connection or an export.
- The accountant reviews and posts them.
Agree on which format and which moment of transfer you will use. This is settled during the analysis, not after go-live.
Also agree which system owns each kind of data. For example, customers and items are created in the ERP, while the chart of accounts stays in accounting. When each kind of data has one home, mismatches disappear.
Involve your accountant from the analysis stage. They know which document details and reports they need, so there are no surprises at the end of the first month.
How we approach it
We don’t replace your accounting software. We run the operations and agree how documents reach your accountant. The hand-over to accounting is built on request, in your accountant’s format. See the invoicing module and the integrations page.